11 Comments
User's avatar
Manuel del Rio's avatar

Great article! Personally, I prefer not to use nihilism as a description for anti-realism because of all the negative connotations it gets given. I find it really, really hard to take moral realism seriously; although I am trying to read the best arguments for it, it just feels like wishful thinking and religious-like belief.

Lance S. Bush's avatar

I never use it outside of this article. I used it in this article to match the way the terminology in the article I was responding to was being used.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
May 29, 2025
Comment deleted
Lance S. Bush's avatar

If that's what he meant he could have just said that. I'd still object even to that. Natural selection doesn't have a bunch of distinctive systems for thinking about specific things. It allows us to think in a more flexible and open-ended sense, which has been adaptive, and as a byproduct of this we might end up thinking up and doing some silly things. Not every byproduct of an adaptation has to enhance our fitness. So thinking about abstract things may be a product of, e.g., recursive thinking, skill at planning, metacognition, the ability to engage in mental simulation, facility with metaphor, and other skills that stem from general cognitive abilities. Those abilities can be adaptive even if existential worrying isn't.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
May 30, 2025
Comment deleted
Rajeev Ram's avatar

This sort of reasoning is used in a lot of different areas, by lots of different people, who want to make claims that aren't empirically substantiated, or may not even be substantiable.

I call it evolutionism: a plausible, hand-wavy appeal to evolution to support a 'common sense' point.

User's avatar
Comment removed
May 27, 2025
Comment removed
Rajeev Ram's avatar

I did not read that as an empirical claim about why the ordinary person should **not** endorse value realism, and I am not sure this is what the author believes, either, though he could. I read it as a claim that there is insufficient empirical evidence that the ordinary person should endorse value realism, which is the thesis of the whole post; and, in particular, as a response to someone who claimed the opposite without the accompanying evidence.

Would it have been clearer if phrased as follows?

"There have been shown no strong pragmatic reasons that an ordinary person ought to endorse value realism."

Comment removed
Jun 1, 2025Edited
Lance S. Bush's avatar

People who accuse me of dishonesty are permanently banned from all future engagement with me.

Rajeev Ram's avatar

> OP clearly claims it's false the ordinary person has pragmatic reason to accept value realism

Sorry, I just don't think your interpretation is correct.

Person 1: Claims X

Person 2: No, you haven't shown X, there is no proof of X, or reason for X.

How is Person 2 dodging a burden of proof?

> You haven't seen any empirical case that "The ordinary person does not have any strong pragmatic reasons to endorse value realism."

Sure, but I'm not sure why empirical evidence is needed to prove the abscence of a claim.